When two businesses use similar marks, they can often agree on where each one operates instead of fighting over it. The agreement can clear a refusal at the USPTO, settle a case before the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board, or keep a dispute from starting.
Consent and Coexistence: The Difference
A consent agreement is usually short. The owner of an earlier mark states that it does not object to another party's registration. It is most often used to answer a likelihood-of-confusion refusal.
A coexistence agreement is broader. It sets out how both marks will be used: the goods or services each owner may sell under its mark, the markets each will serve, how each mark will look, and what the parties will do if confusion arises.
Answering a USPTO Refusal
When an examining attorney refuses an application because of an earlier registered mark, the owner of that mark can consent to the registration. The USPTO weighs the agreement as evidence that confusion is unlikely.
A bare statement of consent carries little weight. An agreement that explains why the parties believe confusion is unlikely, and what each will do to avoid it, carries much more. The examining attorney still decides whether the refusal is overcome.
Settling a Dispute
Many oppositions, cancellations, and trademark disputes end in an agreement rather than a decision. A coexistence agreement settles the conflict on terms both sides accept, and usually provides for withdrawing the Board case or the claim.
Terms That Matter
An agreement that is vague on these points can leave the parties where they started:
- The goods and services each party may use its mark for
- Territories, markets, and channels of trade
- How each mark is displayed, including logos, colors, and house marks
- Each party's future applications and registrations
- What the parties do if actual confusion occurs
- Whether the agreement passes to a buyer of either business
- How long the agreement lasts and how it ends
What the Firm Handles
- Consent agreements to answer likelihood-of-confusion refusals
- Coexistence agreements between owners of similar marks
- Settlement agreements in oppositions and cancellations
- Approaching the owner of an earlier mark
- Review of an agreement proposed by the other side
